‘THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN’: PILL RESIDENTS DEMAND PROTECTION FOR VITAL
LIBRARY SERVICES
PILL, NORTH SOMERSET: The Pill and Easton-in-Gordano Parish Council urges North Somerset
Council Councillors, ahead of their vote in February on the future of library services, to respect the
democratic will of its residents following the recent release of the Library Services Consultation
Summary Report on 14th January.
The report highlights an extraordinary mobilisation of concerned local people in Pill. Despite
constituting less than 3% of the North Somerset population, Pill residents contributed nearly 10%
of the total consultation responses—over three times the expected participation rate (Report page
56). This placed Pill as having the highest level of engagement across the whole of North
Somerset.
The library consultation, conducted from July to October 2025, sought opinions on how North
Somerset Council could implement £433,000 in savings. Results from the Library Services
Consultation Summary Report indicate that Option B, which retains Pill Library under North
Somerset Council management, is the most favoured option amongst North Somerset residents.
Key Findings from the Report:
The “Option B” Mandate: Option B (to retain Pill Library under North Somerset Council
management) received the highest agreement (48%) and the lowest disagreement (25%) among
all three options (A, B and C) proposed by North Somerset Council. (Report page 38)
Opposition to Library Devolution: Respondents overwhelmingly rejected potential site closures,
preferring options such as reduced and unstaffed hours, income generation (e.g., room hires) and
community partnerships over devolution from a North Somerset Council managed service to
community managed library models. (Report page 40, 41, 47, 48, 50)
Community Managed Library Concerns: Residents expressed serious doubts about
“community-managed” library models, recognising the immense pressure it places on local
volunteers and the risk of failure. The majority or respondents (49%) stated that they could not
commit to supporting or helping run a community-managed library. (Report page 50)
Social Impact: In the consultation, North Somerset Council recognised that Pill West is an area of
high community need, as identified within the English Indices of Deprivation 2025 where Pill West
is flagged as one of the most deprived areas in North Somerset. Residents emphasised in their
consultation feedback that the risk of closure would disproportionately affect low-income families,
those with protected characteristics and vulnerable groups relying on the library for improved
literacy, digital access and social connections.
A spokesperson for Pill and Easton-in-Gordano Parish Council stated:
“By overwhelmingly supporting option B of the consultation, our parishioners and wider North
Somerset residents have sent a clear, undeniable message to North Somerset Council Officers,
Councillors and its leadership: Pill Library is an vital and valued local service. The data shows that
residents mobilised in unprecedented numbers to protect this community hub and to ensure that it
continues to be funded and managed by North Somerset Council. By adopting option B, North
Somerset Council can demonstrate its commitment to the public consultation process and
democratic fairness.”
The Parish Council also noted a significant gap in the consultation data: while 17.6% of the local
population is under 20 years old, they accounted for only 1.4% of the respondents. This highlights
the need for the Council to safeguard services for young people, who are recognised as a
protected characteristic under the Equalities Act 2010, but who were clearly significantly underrepresented during the consultation process. (Report page 52)
A New Path Forward: “Option D”
In addition to taking note of the consultation findings, the Pill and Easton-in-Gordano Parish
Council hopes that North Somerset Councillors will further examine the ‘Option D’ proposal put
forward by Green Councillors Jenna Ho-Marris and Joe Tristram. This proposal aims to keep all
North Somerset libraries open by distributing necessary savings more evenly across the entire
service rather than targeting specific branches like Pill and Winscombe for closure.
This proposal reflects a similar strategy previously presented by the Pill and Easton-in-Gordano
Parish Council to North Somerset Council officers in October 2025. The recent shift in political will
was evident at the North Somerset Full Council meeting on November 11, where Councillor Joe
Tristram publicly re-evaluated his initial support for community-funded models. Addressing the
Full Council, Cllr Tristram stated:
“My point of view at the outset was that North Somerset needed to save the money… and that it
wouldn’t make much difference whether the library was run and funded by us or by the parish.
Having heard what has been said during the consultation period, I no longer believe that. It is really
important that we continue funding that library and the others…”
Through further exploration of Option D, Pill and Easton-in-Gordano Parish Council believes North
Somerset can achieve its financial objectives without dismantling the essential library
infrastructure that supports some of North Somerset’s most vulnerable residents.
Media Contact:
Tony Jay
Clerk, Pill & Easton-in-Gordano Parish Council
Email: clerk@peig-pc.gov.uk
Website: peig-pc.gov.uk
Notes to Editors:
About the Consultation: The North Somerset Library Service consultation was launched in 2025 to
address a budget shortfall of £433,000.
About Pill Library: Located in a recognised area of deprivation (Pill West), the library serves as a
primary point for digital inclusion, literacy support, community health, children’s clubs and other
vital services.
The Options: Option A: Communities will be offered the opportunity to manage Pill and
Winscombe libraries. If no viable community-led solutions are found, they may both face closure.
Option B: Pill Library would remain part of the North Somerset Library network, as community
need could be considered high. The community will be offered the opportunity to manage
Winscombe Library. If no viable community-led solution is found, Winscombe Library may face
closure. Option C: Winscombe Library would remain part of the North Somerset Library network. The
community will be offered the opportunity to manage Pill Library. If no viable community-led
solution is found, Pill Library may face closure.
Link to Library Services Consultation Summary Report: https://nsomerset.inconsult.uk/Libraries/consultationHome